Disclaimer: I received copies of The Children, Heather, and Villa Coco from NetGalley and the publishers. This post contains affiliate links.
I started this month with high expectations for my reading. I had some really good NetGalley reads lined up and hoped to catch up on some backlist reads. But The Calamity Club found its way into my library holds, and excited, I dug in. I probably should have DNF'd it, but I was determined to see it to the end. It took me a long time to read, and heading into July, it leaves me falling behind on my prereleases again. So many books, so little time!
Hands down, my favorite book this month was Whistler. Ann Patchett is one of my favorite authors--her prose is beautiful and tells a compelling story like so few authors. Reading it reminded me of how much I love to read!
The Children follows Guinevere and her brother Ennis through their unusual upbringing in a farmhouse in Vermont with completely dysfunctional parents. Their mother is the author of a popular fantasy book series in which they are the main characters, which reminded me of the Chronicles of Narnia. Their childhood was almost magical, until a terrible tragedy takes place. For years, they are estranged, Guin living a purposeless life and Ennis a secretive one. The ending blew me away and gave me all the answers I was seeking. Told in alternating timelines, the narrative travels between the past and the present, peeling away secrets like layers. The writing is absolutely beautiful. What an amazing book!
Ann Patchett is one of those authors who can say so much in so few words.
Whistler may be my favorite of all of her books. While growing up, Daphne and Lida's mother was married 3 times. An accidental encounter with her mother's 2d husband, many years after they split, leads Daphne down a trail of memories, including an accident that she had long forgotten. The reunion with her stepfather and subsequent relationship become the focus of the story. This is a quiet story, but the author deftly weaves through family connections and emotions. I don't want to spoil the story with too many details, but this was just a wonderful read. If I could give it more than 5 stars, I would.
Heather is a small town mystery about twin girls, the disappearance of one of them years ago, along with the discovery of a dead baby. There are also a few subplots, mostly involving Callie, the chief of police. While never preachy, the story and the subplots remind the reader that it's still a man's world. Told in 2 different timelines in the voices of Callie, the twins, and later, a random woman who is nosy and curious, I never struggled with orientation to the story. I found this book to be engaging and interesting, but at times, the narrative dragged, and I admit to skimming at some parts to get ahead, not missing a beat. A little bit of trimming would have helped up the tension as the story built. But I never wanted to quit this one, seeing it to a very satisfying conclusion.
"Our young man", struggling to find his way in life, takes a job in a Tuscan estate, cataloguing the contents for its resident, a 92 year old barroness. When he arrives, he finds a home in chaos and an employer who wants him at her beck and call for all sorts of things, including listening to her tales of a life well lived. The cast of eccentric characters and their antics made me laugh out loud. The prose is beautiful, the Italian setting is lovely, and the story is endearing.
Villa Coco is a wild, magical, coming-of-age tale, and a great escape from the heaviness of the world around us.
Was it just me? I was
excited to read this one, having loved The Help. The Calamity Club started with so much promise. Set during the Great Depression in Oxford, Mississippi, the book follows the stories of several main characters: Meg, an orphan who is oddly adopted by a wealthy young couple, and Birdie, a bright young woman who is drawn into a local family's drama with the intent of visiting her sister and ends up staying much longer than she expected. Wanting to help the family save their home, Birdie devises a plan to operate a pop-up 'dance club' at the house. Entertaining, yes, but at over 600 pages, this book was just way too long. I found myself skimming at times, just to get things moving. A good editor would have cut some of the fluff. And while the burlesque club was entertaining, for me, it was really far-fetched and didn't fit well in the setting of all the strong women the author had developed so well. 3.5 stars
How was your month of reading? Did you read any of these? How willing are you to give up on a book that isn't holding your interest?
I've probably said this before: your reviews are very well written, Wendy!
ReplyDeleteYou manage to pack in so much info in a short paragraph, it's an art. Much like Ann Pratchett saying so much in so few words! I haven't read any of these, but if I would choose one, then definitely "Whistler".
I'm trying to read books in French, which has slowed my reading down significantly. I'm STILL stuck on "The Life List" by Lori Nelson Spielman. It's boring, predictable and slightly annoying, but I'm determined to finish it, ha!
I have enough trouble reading long books in English, lol! I swear, I have ADHD...
DeleteThe only Ann Patchett book I've read to date is The Dutch House and I really really didn't enjoy it. I do audio books 99% of the time, and the only reason I forced myself to finish the book was because Tom Hanks was the narrator and who doesn't like Tom Hanks. So, I've been gun shy about reading one of her other books. Interesting your comments about the Calamity Club. I was recently in 2 books groups on FB and this books comes up ALOT. It seems to get extremely different reviews. People either HATED it or LOVED it. No in between. It's on my hold list through Libby, so we'll see how it goes. The others you mentioned aren't familiar to me.
ReplyDeleteI'm curious to hear what you think about The Calamity Club. I hated the way they decided to raise money to save the family...
DeleteAs always love these reviews. Many of my book choices come from you.
ReplyDeleteSome of them I quit but I just finished one you recommended about animals that can talk. Glad I stuck with it.
I'm glad to hear this!
DeleteI need to check out Dolly All the Time!!!!
ReplyDeleteJust in time for the holiday weekend. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteMy pleasure!
DeleteI picked up The Calamity Club, and then I put it back down. I had my doubts. Great month of reading.
ReplyDeleteYou were right to listen to them. I don't understand all the hype about this book.
DeleteIt's funny how you sometimes pick up a book everyone else seems to love and you just can't see it. It has happened more than once to me lately.
ReplyDeleteMy library doesn't have "The Children", but another book by Melissa Albert, so I might try that one.
Visiting from Share your Shelf
Let me know what you think!!
DeleteThe Children reminded me a bit of AS Byatt's The Children's Book (which was excellent, my goodness I read it a long time ago, v short review here: https://librofulltime.wordpress.com/2011/10/19/a-s-byatt-the-childrens-book/ ) Well done for pushing through The Calamity Club, I'd have given it up!
ReplyDeleteI wish I had given it up! I remember that AS Byatt book--will head over to read your review!
DeleteOh I hate when such a popular book I have high hopes for falls flat... and then I spend so much time wondering what the hype was and why I didn't like it. It sounds like the rest of your books were pretty good though. I've read only 2 Ann Patchett books and I loved one and thought the other was duller than dirt so I'm always torn when I see her stuff come up but I'd be willing to give this on a try.
ReplyDeleteLet me know if you do read it!
DeleteI've heard a lot of good things about Whistler. I've never read her books. I also heard The Calamity Club was good!
ReplyDeleteI'm definitely in the minority about Calamity Club. But you should read it, to see if you like it!
DeleteI've seen a few people recommend Whistler. I'll have to check it out. Calamity Club seems too long for me...haha. Though one IG account I follow LOVED it. Just shows how everyones tastes vary, and it's totally okay, to love or not love a book
ReplyDeleteCalamity Club was definitely long--but IMHO it was too long and could have been trimmed. I also had issues with the 'female empowerment' theme, but using a burlesque club to raise money. Idk. It just wasn't for me.
DeleteWaving hi as I make my blog rounds. Hope you're managing to stay cool during this heat wave.
ReplyDeleteHi! We've cooled off a bit in the Midwest--it's just very humid.
DeleteOoo, I still haven't read any of Ann Patchett's books yet but fully intend to! I'll definitely have to add Whistler to my list! (Same with Heather + Villa Coco! :] ) I've heard good things about Calamity Club but am thinking of moving it further down my TBR list based on your review..
ReplyDeleteApologies on the delay in getting my linkup up this week, haha. It's been so busy. :'(
I read 4 books this month. I haven't read any of these books.
ReplyDeleteI read 4 books this month. I haven't read any of these books. I try to keep going if I'm struggling with a book but if it gets to the point where I don't want to read because of the book I'm reading, I'll give up on it.
ReplyDelete